Media today is falling over itself to provide information on the new kid on the block, but here’s a commendable relic from a time when China was not much noticed by the Western world. Mind you this is from 1902, on a series of lectures by Herbert Allen Giles on China and the Chinese, which I think everybody should enjoy and read or, if you prefer, listen to. If you’re not too interested you’d might want to skim through some of the drier language related parts, but in any case this is remarkably well-written.
Tag Archives: language
As many of you probably know, Chinese characters carry meaning rather than sound. (I know there are also what’s called phono-semantic compounds, but give me a break). In fact though it contains both meaning and sound, and although people speaking in different languages may connect different sounds to the same character, the character always has the same meaning. This has made it possible for various dialects or languages throughout China to exist while still being able to understand each other by writing. Convenient, right?
And this extends not only to mainland China and Taiwan. Japanese, Korean and Vietnamese – all of which are linguistically unrelated to Sinitic languages – have created their own pronunciation for Chinese characters known as Kanji, Hanja and Chữ Nho.
This brings me to the real point of today’s post, which is a funny little tale about the clumsy early adoption of the Chinese system of writing in Japan.
Back in the day, Japanese elites had to learn to read and write in Chinese. Unlike the Chinese however, they had no written language of their own, which led to some bizarre occurrences. For example using the sounds of Chinese characters to form Japanese words, even if the actual meaning was just plain silly. If a Chinese person was to sit down and read the Kojiki, a collection of myths from 8th century Japan, he wouldn’t be able to understand much if it at all despite the fact that it would be written in Chinese characters. If he were to read it out loud, a Japanese person passing by would be able understand it perfectly. The Chinese on the other hand would probably end up seriously worrying about what was wrong with the people of Japan as well as wondering what “secret-tea-sky” meant and if perhaps “wooden-chicken-river-pot” had anything to do with it.